Virtual Reality for Brands
by Patrick Milling-Smith and Rori Duboff
It is easy to get overwhelmed by virtual reality (VR), especially if you consider the phenomenal growth expected over the next few years, with revenues from both software and hardware projected to increase 20x from around $1.8 billion in 2016 to over $37 billion in 2020. If you combine VR with augmented and mixed reality technologies, total worldwide revenues are expected to grow at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 181.3% in the same period, reaching more than $162 billion by 2020. Goldman Sachs has predicted that the AR/VR industry’s revenue will eclipse TV’s by 2025.
Today it seems that almost every week sees the launch of a new device, platform or company, promising to deliver more break-through technology. In the past year alone, technology heavyweights like Samsung, Sony, HTC, Google and Facebook Oculus launched VR devices. Just last month, Microsoft announced a range of Windows 10 headsets with partners Lenovo, Dell, Acer, and HP.
However, it’s important to think of virtual reality as more than just the hardware, more than head mounted displays or goggles, more than consoles and 360 cameras or hand controllers. If we limit our understanding of VR to only the shiny new products for sale, then we fail to recognize the true potential of this evolving media for the long-term.
Virtual reality, like every medium before it, will not grow based on the technology alone, but through a mix of compelling and accessible content that is designed squarely around the fundamental nature of the human condition. More than simply an engaging experience, VR has the potential to surpass all user expectations by feeling emotionally and physically transformative.
The unique power of VR is unlike anything we have seen before due to the intensity of its user experience and impact. Whether through 360º live action video, game engine or computer-generated imagery (CGI), VR has the ability to transform every day moments into life altering experiences that transcend our conventions of space and time. By creating the illusion of 3D depth from 2D images (via stereoscopic display), VR transports people into an immersive 360º world that saturates the mind, body and senses. Such is the power of this sensation that people feel they are physically present within the experience, living it first-hand rather than simply viewing it on a screen.
“VR eliminates the need for external frames. For the first time, the medium is no longer outside us, but within us. The paint is human experience and the canvas is our consciousness. The idea of an externalized medium ceases to exist” — Chris Milk, co-founder, Here Be Dragons
In an age where we are often physically present in one space yet emotionally engaged in another — documenting life rather than truly experiencing it — VR delivers unparalleled ‘in the moment’ presence. Furthermore, as a genuinely first-person medium, VR has the unique potential to create memories. We remember best from our own experiences by doing and trying, rather than merely reading, listening or watching. And it is our memories that form the overriding driver of our brand affinities and purchasing decisions.
Such power to create memories is a key point in Byron Sharp’s book How Brands Grow, when he states: “the dominant way that advertising works is by refreshing and building memory structures. These structures improve the chance of a brand being recalled and/or noticed in buying situations; which in turn increases the chance of a brand being bought. So, to influence behavior, advertising must work with people’s memories.” Thus, VR, unlike any other medium, has the power to create memories that induce deep brand affinity and inspire action.
The profound impact of VR is proven by the UN & Here Be Dragons’ work “Clouds Over Sidra” about the plight of a young Syrian refugee. This VR experience inspired one in six members of the public who viewed it to donate money, twice the average for the UN and UNICEF and over 15x the average response rate to direct marketing. The message is clear – Making people feel often makes them act.
Although we are just at the beginning of the VR evolution, we can already see the amazing potential of this medium to transform the ways we communicate, experience and share the stories of our lives. What was once improbable and unimaginable in traditional media can now be achieved with VR.
Although estimates for mass-market VR adoption have varied, the overall consensus across the industry is that the market will be huge. Now is the time for creatives and marketers to be bold and challenge all preceding conventions and paradigms. Those that lead the way early will be disproportionately rewarded as virtual reality continues its march on the mainstream.
In 1996 the Centre for Creative Leadership published research that went on to underpin the capability building programs of many of the world’s biggest companies. It showed that business executives believed they learnt best from on the job experiences and discussions with their peers as opposed to formal study or training. In that spirit, we both wanted to share the lessons our successes and failures have taught us with other practitioners or those considering VR.
5 Points for Virtual Reality
1. Reinvent, don’t Retrofit
When beginning a VR project, the most fundamental question to ask is what are you trying to achieve through VR that you cannot achieve through any other medium? Why will the experience be meaningful and relevant for your intended audience? VR provides the opportunity to connect and engage with audiences in a fresh new way, so it is important to try new things versus replicating the same. Since VR is radically different to other formats, you should use its unique capabilities to build experiences that can only be achieved within a visceral, 360º immersive space, rather than for a flat screen.
For example – a traditional TV commercial or worse, a 2D web banner, bluntly transposed into a 3D environment won’t work. When your audience is committing to fully engage with a more immersive experience, their expectations need to be met with a ‘ground-up’ reimagining of the campaign for the VR experience. Doing otherwise will ruin the overall experience by breaking the sense of “presence” (the degree to which a person feels truly submerged within a virtual environment).
For brands, VR need not be considered in an independent silo, but as an extension to the overall marketing strategy. Consumer insights regarding media consumption and social behavior, or demographic and attitudinal data should be applied as rigorously to VR as other marketing communications channels, as this research can powerfully inform the successful development of this evolving medium.
2. Step outside the screen. Create for 3D spaces, not 2D frames
Creating in VR often means thinking like an architect because spatial visualization and physical orientation set the narrative construct. In addition, VR tends to alter one’s perception of space and time due to the limited field of view within a headset, so everything seems to be more immediate within VR versus viewing ‘flat’ video.
With so much multi-sensory information to absorb, the experience needs to be deliberately orchestrated to help the user easily navigate their surroundings. Every element in the 360º environment, including sound, action, light and color should be used to help guide the users’ attention.
Rather than composing shots as a filmmaker would, by curating frames for the viewer, VR creators need to think in terms of space, alongside traditional elements such as story, aesthetic and performance. Instead of a traditional shot list, a VR project often starts with a list of environments that the user will experience, along with actions for those environments.
Audio is a significant component for crafting VR experiences as headsets limit spatial awareness and the ears are forced to do much more work. Binaural sound, in which tiny delays between the sound in the right and left ears trick the brain into assigning direction and distance, can help create a true sense of presence.
For more physical VR experiences, particularly within gaming, haptic components such as hand controllers, gloves, and full bodysuits allow users to feel tactile sensations synchronized with the VR experience. Haptic technologies, although not yet mainstream, can create truly intensified levels of engagement by providing an added dimension of reality to VR experiences.
3. Develop storyworlds, not just storylines
Since VR is often told in the first-person point of view, the narrative needs to be constructed such that it enables one to feel that they are living the story, and not just watching a story from the outside.
The narrative in VR should not just be conceived of as a linear story (storylines), but also as iterative experiences that are linked together through common space and themes (storyworlds). The traditional linear narrative can be broken down and reconstructed as something spherical and cyclical to invite user exploration and discovery versus static viewing.
Balancing the narrative between action and atmosphere helps to engage a user without holding their hand too much. Two people rarely experience VR in the same way. ‘Over-directing’ people’s attention can make them feel trapped or bored. Creators who try to exude total control over the narrative will end up creating barriers to engagement, and thus fail to use the medium successfully. Overall, the subtler the clues, the more intuitive the guiding of attention feels, the more accomplishment the user feels in their environment.
There are numerous learnings to apply from the gaming industry for VR, especially as it pertains to fluidity of user experience and seamless navigational interfaces. Game designers establish the space in which players feel free to explore, creating their own adventure and outcomes versus following a preordained path.
An important difference to note between gaming-based VR and non-gaming VR is in regards to user expectations and behaviors. Whereas a hard-core gamer may desire to spend hours and hours battling through immersive VR worlds competing to win, the average VR user probably has less patience and time to commit. Brands developing VR experiences may want to think about starting with a time frame that is no more than two or five minutes, with the potential for episodic programming through an ongoing content series. Non-gaming content experiences in VR still should strive to be fully immersive, however base-level interactions should not require a massive learning curve or intensive sweaty-inducing game-playing sessions.
4. Get up close and Personal. Make the camera a character.
VR puts everything into someone’s intimate space. A close up isn’t just a close up view of someone’s face. Often, you are literally standing so close to them you could feel their breath. It’s a powerful tool that works quite differently than its cousin in rectangular filmmaking.
It’s important to shoot for both clarity and stability, because one always has to consider that the camera is a human being. You would not (generally) yell in a human’s face, nor would you whip them around with quick pans or twisting crane shots. Always consider that the camera is your eventual audience. To design the most immersive and approachable experience you need to think about how the user will experience your work, particularly in terms of personal proximity.
When taking someone through an experience, you need to give them time to explore and take in their surrounding environment. Cutting from scene to scene quickly undoes the story because in reality a viewer would never be thrown from circumstance to circumstance in such an aggressive way. Giving the user’s senses a chance to calibrate and become a part of the experience is fundamental to establishing presence in virtual space.
Exhilarating experiences (flying, looking down from breathtaking heights) certainly have their place in VR, but movement is something that must be done very carefully, otherwise users can become nauseous. One poor experience could keep people from putting on a headset in the future. Movement should mostly be done gradually, and it works best when going forward, backward, up or down. Rotations and pans can disorient the viewer. Fast movement is not out-of-the-question, but there would need to be a logical reason for it and it would need to be well placed.
At the same time, movement is a terrific tool for storytelling, as in Chris Milk’s VR experience “The Evolution of Verse,” in which the viewer floats upward above a lake and into a magical tunnel. As VR rig configurations improve, there will be more opportunities to incorporate movement successfully, and improved headsets will reduce the risk of making viewers nauseous.
5. Transcend the now
The amazing potential of VR is its ability to transport the user to an entirely separate world removed from their immediate surroundings. In real life our attention span is scattered across a wide range of media, whether we are speaking on the phone while walking or watching TV while sending emails. In contrast to such multi-tasking and multi-screening behavior, VR absorbs 100% of a user’s attention because they physically have something blocking their eyes from real world distractions. The audience has chosen, and sought out, this total immersion and engagement.
In fact, people using VR become so singularly absorbed in the experience, that their emotions and senses become even more heightened than they might normally be in the physical world. Virtual experiences can feel so vivid that it often feels like a magnifying glass lens is intensifying everything – from the sun’s glare on water, the dripping sweat or crinkles of a forehead, or the shaking vibrations of a creaking table. You see, feel and experience these things even more acutely in VR because you have no peripheral view beyond what is immediately surrounding you.
Since VR worlds have no real world boundaries to limit the imagination or experience, creators can literally “shoot for the stars” when it relates to developing ideas. From inside a human body to far away galaxies, to past, present or future, anything is possible as long as you have the talent and resources to create it.
For brands, artists, companies and consumers, this opens up a whole new way of thinking about content. Instead of distributing via 2D media, or layering content into our existing 3D space, you can transport people to entirely new worlds of reality.
The potential to evoke emotions (i.e. awe, wonderment and empathy), enrich people’s lives (learning, adventure, social connection) and empower or impact thinking is transformational through these cognitively rich experiences.
Audience Distribution & Engagement
Equally important to creating amazing VR content is making sure that the VR content is distributed and discoverable on a mass scale. However, for most, VR is not yet an accessible medium. Despite massive press coverage over the past year, many people remain confused – they do not fully understand what VR encompasses or why and how they should use the medium in their daily lives. Such confusion is understandable considering the many different devices and incompatible platforms being marketed.
Price has also been a prohibitive factor, particularly for high-end devices like the Oculus Rift or HTC Vive. The cost for these head mounted displays, along with the computers to operate such high-powered devices, is still relatively high. Fewer than 2 million high-end headsets were sold in 2016, with an estimated breakdown of approximately 243,000 Oculus headsets, 420,000 HTC Vive headsets, and 745,000 Sony headsets sold. Such high-end VR devices (PC + console) are projected to reach over 20 million by 2020, and this figure may increase if Sony is able to fully capitalize on their already installed PlayStation VR base of more than 50 million.
The real driver growth in VR for now and the next few years will most likely not be from high-end devices, but from mobile VR. Lower-priced devices, including Google Cardboard, Daydream, and Samsung Gear VR accounted for 98% of all units sold in 2016. According to Samsung, approximately five million Gear headsets were shipped globally by end of 2016.
By 2020, sales of smartphone VR headsets (mobile VR) are expected to surge fivefold, rising to over 60 million (totaling approx. 90 million if you include all headsets) Most of these devices do not provide the level of total true immersion and agency that a fully navigable VR experience in HTC Vive offers, but the population that can be reached is sizably larger and experiences can still be transformative for the user.
Figure 1: VR device projections: Global forecast (unit shipment in millions)
Source: Greenlight Insights & Road to VR; 2016 Virtual Reality Industry Report
The number of devices sold is not the only indicator of VR usage, because we expect significant usage through location-based VR at events, roadshows, pop-up installations, showrooms, theaters and other multi-media venues. This month, IMAX launched its first VR theater in Los Angeles and over the next three years IMAX is planning to open a total of twenty-five VR theaters around the world. In China, there are already 3,000 VR Internet arcades that have laucnhed. A wide variety of brands such as Pepsi, AT&T, Audi, Honda, MasterCard, GE, Nike and Adidas have created these location-based VR experiences to connect with their audiences in powerful new ways.
Quite possibly the most mainstream channel for distributing VR content will be the Web, either through 360º video browsers like You Tube or through WebVR, an emerging medium for 3D content. We expect that over the next few years, VR content and experiences will start weaving their way into our daily lives in a much broader range of occasions.
In 2014 there were around 200,000 users of VR and in 2018 there will be about 170 million users – that is an 85,000% increase according to Credit Suisse and Kzero Worldwide research.
As the market continues to develop, brands will need to make strategic decisions about which devices, platforms and places are the right fit for their objectives. A common challenge is achieving a balance between maximizing audience reach and levels of immersion /user engagement.
Outlined in the chart below is an overview of the various VR devices, platforms and places that brands can consider when then developing, distributing and activating VR experiences.
Figure 2: VR Distribution & Activation: Device, Platforms, Places
Creating multiple paths of engagement, along with a range of cross-platform experiences united by a common narrative thread, will likely serve marketers best. Amplifying VR experiences across social networks and within real world communities (via location-based VR) will help extend brand visibility, reach and engagement.
Industry & Media Applications
The gaming world has helped pave the way for the VR industry, representing approximately 42% of a software market worth $331 million in 2106. However, over the next few years, as the VR software market is expected to grow to more than $19 billion by 2020, game-based VR will only represent 27% of total consumer and business revenue.
Growth will be in categories beyond gaming, including industries such as entertainment and healthcare, journalism and manufacturing, education, retail, real estate and many others. There is a range of opportunities available for brands, from developing original or sponsored VR experiences to creating new business models for consumer engagement.
As VR requires significant investment to produce, brand sponsored and ad-supported experiences can help offset some of the costs, while enabling brands to take advantage of the power of this new medium. Research has shown that consumers are often willing to view ads in exchange for free access to content, versus paid. According to an IBB Consulting survey, 42% of consumers would watch virtual reality ads in exchange for free content and 38% would watch ads as long as they are “cool and relevant”.
However, unlike other mediums that may be more permissive of intrusive advertising, we strongly believe that advertising in VR must be native to the experience. It is absolutely crucial that brands recognize VR is a user-centric medium, whereby users are not just sporadically viewing experiences, but consciously choosing to inhabit and participate in an immersive experience.
Branded media and advertising in VR is still in its very nascent stages, but outlined in the chart below are eight different potential brand VR applications, all of which are still evolving and just being initially explored.
Figure 3: VR Brand Media Applications
A great example of original VR branded content is GE’s The Possible, a five-part documentary series, which lets people experience the most life-changing innovations of our time. Users can come face-to-face with the world’s most advanced robots, explore space and ride a hover
board, and access science not yet shared with the public. Beyond just talking about innovation, GE is using VR to demonstrate its potential and application in the real world, thus truly bringing to life the idea of ‘Imagination at Work’.
Sponsored brand VR activations, such as Samsung’s Night Before holiday experience, demonstrate the power of VR to stimulate people in real world environments. From conception, VR was an integral component of Samsung’s 2016 “Gift of Galaxy” holiday campaign. At select venues in New York City and Los Angeles, participants had the opportunity to take a magical sleigh ride with Santa and his helpers across a blend of virtual and physical worlds. The experience was also amplified across a range of integrated touch points including: Samsung mobile VR, 360º video on YouTube and other video platforms, social channels such as Facebook and Twitter, and out-of-home in select locations across the USA.
Across all industries, from retail to automotive, healthcare, travel, design, journalism, education and real estate, we see that numerous brands are already using VR to better engage consumers, as well as sell product and guide business transformation.
To continue fueling brand investment in VR, it is critical that we apply standards for measurement and success. The role of data analytics is crucial for guiding successful VR strategies. Traditional brand metrics such as awareness, affinity, purchase intent and loyalty/advocacy remain relevant performance indicators. However, much richer dimensions can be captured in virtual environments, not previously available in 2D spaces. For instance, heat-mapping tools can track and visualize user interactions within virtual environments, showing how people interact with content from a multitude of dimensions, such as proximity, duration, and intensity.
Conclusion / Future VR
The future for VR is not easy to predict since we are in the early stages of this undeniably powerful new medium. After all, who would have expected back in the mid 1990s that Facebook, Snapchat or Uber would be invented? We all know that technology can lead to massive progress, but the path towards that is often filled with bumps in the road, surprises and failures. The best most successful outcomes in VR are things we might not have even imagined yet.
The expectation is that devices over time will continue to become less expensive, more accessible and less bulky, easier to use (wireless, lighter and overall more ergonomically designed). The activation energy required to engage with VR (i.e. put on the headsets) should eventually become less of a usage obstacle.
In parallel, VR experiences will also become more immersive with higher fidelity through greater field of view and foveated imaging, facial and body tracking, as well as haptic feedback. Beyond gaze-controlled interaction, we will see a shift from eye as a controller to the full body as a controller, which enables more responsive and immersive VR experiences.
Social VR will also be a massive area of growth, as we shift from isolated experiences to virtual communities that live in real parallel time with our physical worlds. We will develop identities within VR through virtual avatars that allow for true sense of embodiment, meaning that the person breathing, talking and moving in VR will feel uncannily like the self.
As VR develops, and especially as technologies such as artificial intelligence further power experiences, we are likely to see business transformations across multiple industries. Related technologies such as augmented and mixed reality will also progress, potentially merging with VR in certain situations, as with products like Intel’s Project Alloy.
A positive sign of any nascent technology’s readiness for mainstream adoption is often a unification of its industry standards. The Global Virtual Reality Association (GVRA) was recently established by Facebook, Alphabet Google, Sony, Samsung, HTC and Acer, with a goal to promote development and adoption of VR globally. Issues such as privacy and data tracking, as well as ethical practices in these new virtual worlds, all need to be discussed and agreed upon by society at large.
Ultimately, as price becomes less of an issue and user adoption increases, the deciding factor for the success of VR will be the content and experiences. If we want people to take the time to engage and stay engaged in VR, we need to create experiences that go beyond the average and achieve the amazing – evoking awe, wonderment and other meaningful responses. The transportive magic of VR is that it lets people be or do something that they can’t experience in real life.
Connecting with users in such a direct and immersive media obliges brands to elevate their efforts, striving for purpose-driven and user-centric experiences, versus overtly commercial messaging. For, if there is one thing we know it’s that superficial content leads to superficial responses. It is through deeper and more meaningful experiences that brands can create more memorable connections that drive action.
SuperData, Jan 2017
IDC, Worldwide Semiannual Augmented and Virtual Reality Spending Guide, Aug 2016
Goldman Sachs Global Investment Research, Virtual & Augmented Reality: Understanding the Race for the Next Computing Platform, Jan 2016
UN & Here Be Dragons (formerly VRSE), Clouds Over Sidra, Jan 2015
SuperData, Jan 2017
SuperData, Jan 2017 / Greenlight Insights & Road to VR, Nov 2016
HyperGrid Business / SuperData, Nov 2016
Greenlight Insights & Road to VR, Nov 2016
Niko Partners; China VR Games Market, Dec 2016
SuperData, Jan 2017
Interactive Broadband Consulting Group (IBB), April 2016
GE & Here Be Dragons, The Possible, Jan 2017
Samsung & Here Be Dragons, Night Before VR Holiday experience, Dec 2016